SECTION FIVE: TOWARDS THE HOME AND SMALL OFFICE: TELEPHONY AND ISDN
To understand the main technologies used in the worldwide telephone network.
On completing this section you should be familiar with the main features of the telephone network, both analogue and digital, including its use for transferring data.
Until recently it was usual to have separate courses on telecommunications and on data communications - "never the twain shall meet". It was also assumed that the analogue telephone network would rapidly wither away under the impact of ISDN and broadband, so that future generations of network engineers would be spared the tedium (as many digital engineers saw it) of mastering analogue techniques. Unfortunately, this withering away has not happened - digitisation of the telephone network essentially still stops at the local exchange and the modem market is still buoyant despite yearly predictions of its demise. Indeed with the advent of the Internet, it is realistic to plan for every house having a modem in it to connect to the World Wide Web and similar services. (Some old-timers may recall that this universal access was supposed to happen at least 20 years ago - in the era of viewdata/videotex, so that it can hardly be called a new-fangled idea.)
Recommended Reading Read Tanenbaum Chapter 2 Section 2.4 (pages 102 to 139). You can skim-read the subsection on modems (page 109 to 115). You should read the description of the US telephone network because the model is influential outside the US and the thinking behind this is embedded in most of the main vendors (who are US-located or dominated by the needs of the US market). From page 134 onwards (the Switch Hierarchy) you can begin to skim again. |
Activity 4.1 Do problems 14 and 15 of Chapter 2 of Tanenbaum (page 171). |
A modem, standing for modulator-demodulator, converts outgoing digital data into analogue signals over the telephone line, and converts incoming analogue signals back into digital data.
A potted history with a personal slant
Over the last 20 years, the progress in the functionality, size and cost of modems has been amazing (though not so amazing as the progress in microcomputers). In the mid 1970s when I started with dial-up computing, modems were large wooden boxes (nicely made) rented from the Post Office which transmitted data at 110 bit/s, or 300 bit/s for an advanced model. Within a few years, the advent of viewdata (the earliest online service, when most developers of the Internet were still in nappies) had pushed the speed up to 1200 bit/s - although (and it was seen as an aberration at the time, not a strategy) the speed in the reverse direction was a miserly 75 bit/s. It took a long time for the speed to rise to 2400 bit/s in both directions. That was a plateau, then speeds rose to 9600, 14400 and 28800. That was by some people called the "final generation" of modems. Many people firmly believed that ISDN would sweep all this away. Speeds rose a little in the last two years to 33600 bit/s but one could see Shannon's theorem biting.
What few people thought of was to take advantage of the networks which combined analogue and digital communications. Rockwell and US Robotics did, and have come out with 2-way 56000 bit/s modem (with a deal of fudging about the actual speed of the reverse channel).
Recommended Reading Read very carefully in Tanenbaum Chapter 2 subsection 2.4.3 the little section on modems. Take it slowly - this is concentrated stuff but the complete theory is there. There are many other textbooks which cover much the same ground. |
Modem standards
There are a number of modem standards in common use today. They are known as "V" standards, which is the letter used for data communications over analogue lines in the nomenclature of the ITU-T (formerly CCITT) standards body for telecommunications. We shall not in this Unit consider the Bell standards previously widely used in North America for lower-speed modems, since they are rapidly being overtaken by the ITU-T standards.
In addition to these ITU-T standards, from time to time modem vendors, normally very keen on standards, "break ranks" and produce a new "industry standard" just to leapfrog the competition. Usually after a year or two things settle down and the international standards bodies catch up.
This happened with V.34, there was a pre-V.34 industry standard called V.32terbo for modems running at around 28800 bit/s; and minor extensions to V.34 were introduced to produce modems running at 33600 bit/s.
Many commentators described V.34 as the "final generation" of modems, believing that (a) vendors were getting close to the theoretical limits imposed by Shannon's theorem, and (b) the success of ISDN would mean that modem vendors would no longer have the incentive (or cash) to invest in the high levels of R&D to produce a new generation of modems. Note that the modem industry is an unusual sector of the computing industry - normally in the computing industry advances (for example in processor speed or memory size) are doublings or order of magnitude (ten-fold) increases; but in the modem industry speed increases of around 15% (28800 to 33400) are seen as giving a competitive edge.
Well, as so often, the final generation turned out not to be final, as a generation of "56K" modems has been developed.
56K modems
Various developers were trying to push the speed of modems up beyond 33600 bit/s, and they have based their work on one key insight: the signal/noise assumptions in the telephone network (see Shannon's theorem) no longer apply for the typical modem application. This is for two linked reasons:
1 The main use for modems is now to link a PC at home or office to an Internet provider.
2 In such a link, only the path from the home/office to the local exchange is analogue: the rest is digital because (a) the trunk network is digital and (b) any Internet provider now has digital connections to its access points - thus the characteristics of that path are much better and much more predictable than the full range of telephone connections.
The area of 56 kbit/s modem technology was first proposed to the public by Rockwell in a series of announcements around August 1996, under the codename "K56".
This was followed in October 1996 by announcements from Texas Instruments and US Robotics, concerning the 56K modem technology called "x2".
Rockwell continued the escalation by using the codename "K56Plus" and "K56flex" - no doubt assuming that developers will read into it a promise of perhaps 64 kbit/s modems or even higher speeds.
By amending the FCC regulations in the USA so that higher signal levels are allowed - speeds of 56 kbit/s "and potentially higher rates" could be achieved. It is possible that higher signal levels are already allowed in some countries.
The standard adopted for 56k modems is V.90.
There are several difficulties that may arise during the field trials of modems. The industry has already had two bad experiences with fast modem technology which appeared to work well in the lab but not in the real world:
1 There is strong evidence that many "stretched" V.34 modems connect at the 33.6 kbit/s speed on less than 40% of all occasions they are used.
2 There has been a long saga of disappointment with cable modems, where a technology originally developed for broadband LANs simply did not stand up to the reality of the average cable TV network.
If the technical difficulties are overcome then this technology could, in some European countries where ISDN tariffs are still high, cut deeply into the home-based ISDN market or postpone its very existence in some countries. However, it is true that industry commentators see less pressure from the 56K technology on the office-based ISDN market, which is a little less cost-sensitive and where other features of ISDN (like fast call set-up) play a larger role in selection of technologies.
Modem vendors
There are a mass of modem vendors but only a few industry leaders. Based on a casual survey in the Usenet Newsgroup comp.dcom.modems, here are the top names that crop up (not all the top names are the same every year):
Chip vendors
Although there are hundreds of modem manufacturers, there are very few manufacturers of the digital signal processing chips which make up the "heart" of a modern modem. Two of the big names are:
Texas Instruments make the chip at the heart of the 56k technology from US Robotics, it is the signal processing chip which when driven by the software developed by US Robotics delivers the 56k technology.
Rockwell make the chip set which is used by Motorola, Hayes and others.
Data compression
In addition to the "raw" speed of modems, further speed increases have been obtained over the years by the techniques of data compression.
The basic mechanism of data compression is to recognise patterns in the byte stream presented to a modem and find more compact ways of representing it. An interesting early example of data compression was Morse Code, because in Morse Code, the more frequently used symbols had shorter representations. Here are some more modern examples:
Two main algorithms have become popular. Most modern modems implement both:
The upshot of all this work on compression is that the serial port on a computer should be set at about 4 times the modem throughput rate: thus for a 28800 bit/s modem, the serial port should be at 112000 bit/s. You will not always get this throughput, certainly not on arbitrary data, but on certain text and image files you will.
The use of compression techniques has led a number of excitable modem vendors to promote their modems as "faster than ISDN". Of course, the compression techniques can be used on ISDN too - but for some reason, in the early days of ISDN they were not.
Note that older PCs cannot run their serial ports reliably at high speeds (above 14400) - if you have one of these you should get an upgrade to your serial port or else use an internal modem which connects directly to the PC's bus.
The main uses of modems were covered in Section One. Why not re-read Section 1.3 there? As said earlier, the main use now is to link microcomputers (at homes or small offices) into central services. These central services are mainly Internet-based.
Activity 4.2 Do problems 9 and 16 of Chapter 2 of Tanenbaum (page 171). |
Activity 4.3 Establish prices for various modems, (in terms of standards and manufacturer). How do the costs of these modems compare? |
ISDN was covered briefly in Section One. You may want to re-read that to refresh your memory.
ISDN stands for Integrated Services Digital Network. It is a digital enhancement of the usual telephone service which allows data to be sent over telephone lines at speeds rather faster than the fastest modems in common use. The call set-up time for ISDN is also fast - much faster than for a modem to make a connection.
In most countries, an ISDN call costs the same as a telephone call.
ISDN was specified by the CCITT in the early 1980s but it was many years until it became deployed. Even now, it is only in perhaps France and Germany that its use could be called widespread. There are various things that have caused problems for ISDN:
1 Some European countries do not yet have ISDN. (Now that Europe is much "bigger to the East" than it was, there are many more less-advanced countries in Europe than there were ten years ago.) This makes it impossible to use ISDN alone for pan-European networks.
2 In many countries, including the UK, the equipment to make use of ISDN has until recently been expensive, and there was little choice of brands.
3 ISDN has a 16 kbit/s signalling channel, the D channel, potentially available. This would be very useful for X.25 or perhaps low-speed Internet services (such as for email) but in many countries it is not yet available to users.
4 The connection charge for ISDN is quite high in some countries such as the UK.
5 Many of the applications for ISDN commonly suggested by PTTs have a rather "antique" flavour and may not be relevant to modern networks. Dubiously relevant applications include high-quality fast fax machines and photo-videotex.
Vendors seem mainly interested in two main areas:
1 Replacement of modems was supposed to allow users to move from data transfer speeds of 2400 bit/s up to 64 kbit/s. This was an increase of speed of some 25 times. However, now many users have 56 kbit/s modems, so that the arguments for modem replacement have to be more subtle. (One remaining advantage of ISDN is that the set-up time for calls is minimal compared with the "training time" of a modem, that is, the time that it takes for a modem to settle down to do data communications.)
2 Linking of Local Area Networks is the other key area. ISDN can be used to supply additional bandwidth on demand and/or backup to leased digital circuits.
Many commentators in the past have thought that ISDN is a technology in search of an application. They argued that often-proposed ISDN applications like high-quality fax do not seem very useful on the mass scale, compared with modern electronic mail.
However, some sectors have taken up ISDN in quite a large way.
There is a great deal of use of ISDN for videoconferencing in education.
ISDN is having a significant effect on teleworking. This is because ISDN allows one's favourite applications on the LAN to be available in one's own living room.
There are also several interesting applications in the publishing sector - these include:
1 Sending PostScript files to typesetting bureaux. (This is because PostScript files are very large.)
2 Supplying images to clients from colour scanner bureaux.
3 Access to photo libraries.
4 Instant "fonefonts" - that is, accessing typefaces over a network instead of accessing them from a CD-ROM.
5 Advertising agencies sending roughs of artwork to clients.
6 Occasional linking LANs - such for production of a weekly magazine where the production operation runs over only a few days in the week.
7 Remote technical support of users, by using screen-sharing software.
Applications profiles for ISDN
These are likely to break down into three main kinds:
1 Doing old things faster - such as replacing modem access to a server by ISDN access.
2 Doing new things. The obvious example is video communications.
3 Doing things which did not work well on analogue networks.
We argue that many business users require the following types of communication system:
1 electronic mail
2 computer conferencing, bulletin boards, etc
3 teleconferencing with audio
4 teleconferencing with some "visual" assistance - telewriting, audio-visual conferencing, video conferencing
5 database access
6 "time-sharing" (now thought of as Network Computer access to servers)
7 "LAN interconnect"
8 group communications, telepresence,...
ISDN could enhance most of these services. We predict that the ones that will become most important are the following:
a) Video conferencing for meetings, presentations, etc
b) Fast multi-media electronic mail
c) Remote access to Internet and LANs
d) Audio-graphics for tele-assistance, including teaching and training
Recommended Reading Read Tanenbaum Chapter 2 Section 2.5 and the first page of Section 2.6. |
Some applications of ISDN have been covered in outline above. Case studies may be found on the WWW.
3.4 Products, vendors and online resources
There are many vendors of ISDN equipment. In particular the US vendors have discovered ISDN as a product, even if the deployment is patchy within the continental US. However, there are many vendors with specific national or European orientations - how long this will last is not clear.
ISDN access services
Two main service providers are:-
ISDN products
There are many kinds of products associated with ISDN. The most relevant are:
1 ISDN adaptors: these link a PC to an ISDN line. They can be internal cards or external boxes. If external, then depending on the model, they can be linked to the PC by serial port, parallel port, or Ethernet. Most modem vendors (US Robotics, Motorola, etc) and most telecommunications operators (including BT) sell ISDN adaptors.
2 ISDN bridges or routers: these link a LAN to an ISDN line, for back-up or top-up to leased line connections, or in some cases for occasional-use links. The main LAN vendors (Cisco, Bay, 3Com, etc) tend to sell ISDN routers, but there are also some specialist firms such as Ascend.
3 ISDN-based products, of which the most popular are ISDN-based videoconferencing systems.
Activity 4.7 What are the key choice factors that would make you buy a ISDN adaptor for use at home? |
Activity 4.8 Estimate how many Mb of data per month you send and receive via electronic mail (including attachments). If this was sent to your home via ISDN, how much would it cost you per month? Suppose you added to this all your WWW surfing, how would the costs change? |